WSJ Analysis Suggests Elon Musk's DOGE Holdings May Not Be Worth $55 Billion

The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), overseen by Tesla CEO Elon Musk, has been found to overstate its savings from federal spending cuts.

What Happened

The DOGE, which has been promoting cuts amounting to $55 billion, primarily from canceled DEI and climate contracts, might not be as successful as it says. An analysis of government contract data indicates that the actual savings may be much lower, potentially around $2.6 billion over the next year if spending levels remain unchanged. Only about 2% of the funds would have gone to DEI-related contracts.

Key Findings

  • Research-focused agencies, including the Education Department and the Department of Health and Human Services, were the primary targets of these budget cuts.
  • DOGE canceled contracts valued at over $900 million last year, affecting more than 60 agreements with the Department of Health and Human Services.
  • Government contracts involving over 500 companies have been published on the DOGE website, including a canceled contract with Leidos that was valued at approximately $230 million.

Controversy Surrounding DOGE

The findings come in the wake of previous controversies surrounding DOGE. Last week, DOGE faced criticism when its website, which was supposed to host all departmental updates, was found to be completely blank. Mark Cuban, a longtime advocate for reducing government size and enhancing efficiency, criticized Musk on social media because of this.

The ‘DOGE Dividend’

The ‘DOGE dividend’, endorsed by President Donald Trump and Elon Musk, which proposes to return 20% of the savings from DOGE initiatives to American citizens, has raised eyebrows. Experts have cautioned that spending the savings would reduce the effectiveness of the entire effort. Meanwhile, estimates suggest that with nearly $2 billion in budget deficit, $4 billion in DOGE savings would translate to just $2.42 per person if evenly distributed.

Conclusion

The analysis suggests that the actual savings from DOGE’s federal spending cuts may be significantly lower than initially claimed. As the controversy surrounding DOGE continues to grow, it remains to be seen how the department will address these concerns and provide accurate information to the public.

Additional Resources

For more information on this topic, please see the following articles:

  • Elon Musk’s DOGE Reports Nearly $4.7 Trillion Untraceable In Federal Payments, Makes TAS Tag Mandatory
  • Tesla Begins Hiring For Cybercab Manufacturing As Elon Musk-Led EV Giant Prepares For Robotaxi Rollout